Look-alikes

Northern Mockingbird vs Gray Catbird

Two slim gray songbirds, both brilliant mimics — but they live differently. Mockingbirds own open lawns and sing all night; catbirds skulk in hedgerows and mew like a cat.

Northern Mockingbird, verified photograph
Northern Mockingbird — photo: Wikimedia Commons
Gray Catbird, verified photograph
Gray Catbird — photo: Wikimedia Commons
Field markNorthern MockingbirdGray Catbird
ColorPale gray above, whitish belowDarker slate gray, nearly uniform; black cap; rusty patch under the tail
Wings and tailLong tail with white outer feathers; big white wing patches that flash in flightDark tail, plain dark wings — no white patches
VoiceRepeats each borrowed phrase three or more times; often sings at nightA jumbled continuous warble without repeating phrases, plus a 'mew' like a cat
BehaviorRuns and hops on open lawns, aggressively defends berry bushesSkulks in dense thickets and hedges, tail cocked
DietInsects in summer, fruit heavily in fall and winterSame mix — both are drawn to fruit plantings
WinterStays through winter across most of the U.S.Most migrate to the Gulf states and tropics

Field tips

  • White wing flashes in flight = mockingbird. A rusty patch under a black-capped gray tail = catbird.
  • A gray bird singing at 2 a.m. from a power line is almost always a Northern Mockingbird.
  • Plant serviceberry, dogwood or elderberry and both species will claim it — often noisily disputing ownership.

Full species profiles

Where and when to expect the Northern Mockingbird

Across the 35 US states and Canadian provinces where we have range data for the Northern Mockingbird, it is a year-round resident in 34, a summer breeder in 1, a winter visitor in 0. That makes it largely resident: in most of its range the same birds use a yard through every season, so a steady year-round food and water supply pays off.

Nesting starts earliest in Alabama (February–August) and latest in West Virginia (March–August) — a 1-month spread driven by latitude and spring warm-up. Insect food and nest sites matter most in your own region's window.

Where and when to expect the Gray Catbird

Across the 55 US states and Canadian provinces where we have range data for the Gray Catbird, it is a year-round resident in 2, a summer breeder in 53, a winter visitor in 0. That makes it largely migratory: most backyards see it for part of the year only, so feeding and planting should be timed to its arrival.

Nesting starts earliest in Alabama (April–July) and latest in Wyoming (June–July) — a 2-month spread driven by latitude and spring warm-up. Insect food and nest sites matter most in your own region's window.

Native plants that feed mockingbirds

Ranked by how many states and provinces list each plant for the Northern Mockingbird. Planting these supplies food when feeders are empty and insects for nestlings.

  • Smooth sumac Rhus glabra

    Shrub · listed in 31 regions. Red fruit heads hang on through winter.

  • Eastern red cedar Juniperus virginiana

    Tree · listed in 28 regions. Dense evergreen roost cover and bluish 'berries' eaten through winter.

  • Flowering dogwood Cornus florida

    Tree · listed in 28 regions. Fat-rich red fall fruit taken by thrushes, bluebirds and woodpeckers.

Full guide: how to attract mockingbirds →

Native plants that feed catbirds

Ranked by how many states and provinces list each plant for the Gray Catbird. Planting these supplies food when feeders are empty and insects for nestlings.

  • Smooth sumac Rhus glabra

    Shrub · listed in 49 regions. Red fruit heads hang on through winter.

  • Eastern red cedar Juniperus virginiana

    Tree · listed in 38 regions. Dense evergreen roost cover and bluish 'berries' eaten through winter.

  • Serviceberry Amelanchier arborea

    Tree · listed in 38 regions. Early-summer berries arrive exactly when nestlings are being fed.

Full guide: how to attract catbirds →

Frequently asked

How many songs can a mockingbird know?

Northern Mockingbirds commonly learn more than 200 song types in a lifetime, copying other birds, frogs, even machinery — and each phrase is repeated several times in succession.

Why does a catbird 'meow'?

The mew call is the Gray Catbird's signature contact and alarm call. Its long song is a different, continuous jumble of notes with no repeats — unlike the mockingbird.

Which one nests in my yard?

Mockingbirds nest in open shrubs in lawns, parks and suburbs; catbirds prefer dense hedgerows and thickets. Both build cup nests a few feet off the ground.

Sources

  1. Northern Mockingbird — All About Birds, Cornell Lab of Ornithology
  2. Gray Catbird — All About Birds, Cornell Lab of Ornithology
  3. Gray Catbird — Audubon Guide to North American Birds

Timing reflects typical patterns for the region as a whole; local dates vary with elevation and year. Check the linked eBird bar charts for your county.