Red-tailed Hawk vs Red-shouldered Hawk
These two buteos are confused most often in the East, where Red-shouldered Hawks overlap with young and light-morph Red-tails. Tail banding, breast pattern and habitat separate them cleanly.


| Field mark | Red-tailed Hawk | Red-shouldered Hawk |
|---|---|---|
| Adult tail | Brick-red above, unmarked; pale below | Black with narrow white bands |
| Breast | Pale with a band of dark streaks across the belly | Warm rusty-orange barring across breast and belly |
| Size | 17–26 in; broad wings, stocky | 16–24 in; slimmer, with longer tail |
| Voice | Classic raspy 'keeeeeer' scream | Repeated whistled 'kee-yah, kee-yah' — often noisy in spring |
| Habitat | Open country, fields, roadsides; perches on poles | Bottomland forest, rivers and swamps; perches inside trees |
| Hunting | Still-hunting from high perches, soaring over open ground | Drops from a low perch onto frogs, snakes and small mammals near water |
Field tips
- A banded black-and-white tail means Red-shouldered, at any age.
- Habitat is a strong clue: poles and open fields = Red-tailed; wooded streams = Red-shouldered.
- Red-shouldered Hawks often reuse the same territory for years and are unusually vocal around nests.
Full species profiles
Where and when to expect the Red-tailed Hawk
Across the 58 US states and Canadian provinces where we have range data for the Red-tailed Hawk, it is a year-round resident in 56, a summer breeder in 2, a winter visitor in 0. That makes it largely resident: in most of its range the same birds use a yard through every season, so a steady year-round food and water supply pays off.
Nesting starts earliest in Alabama (January–June) and latest in Yukon (March–June) — a 2-month spread driven by latitude and spring warm-up. Insect food and nest sites matter most in your own region's window.
Where and when to expect the Red-shouldered Hawk
Across the 42 US states and Canadian provinces where we have range data for the Red-shouldered Hawk, it is a year-round resident in 38, a summer breeder in 4, a winter visitor in 0. That makes it largely resident: in most of its range the same birds use a yard through every season, so a steady year-round food and water supply pays off.
Nesting starts earliest in Alabama (February–June) and latest in Wisconsin (April–June) — a 2-month spread driven by latitude and spring warm-up. Insect food and nest sites matter most in your own region's window.
Native plants that feed red-tailed hawks
Ranked by how many states and provinces list each plant for the Red-tailed Hawk. Planting these supplies food when feeders are empty and insects for nestlings.
- American elderberry Sambucus canadensis
Shrub · listed in 44 regions. Late-summer berry clusters taken by over 40 bird species.
- Black cherry Prunus serotina
Tree · listed in 43 regions. Summer fruit and one of the top caterpillar host trees.
- Serviceberry Amelanchier arborea
Tree · listed in 39 regions. Early-summer berries arrive exactly when nestlings are being fed.
Full guide: how to attract red-tailed hawks →
Native plants that feed red-shouldered hawks
Ranked by how many states and provinces list each plant for the Red-shouldered Hawk. Planting these supplies food when feeders are empty and insects for nestlings.
- American elderberry Sambucus canadensis
Shrub · listed in 41 regions. Late-summer berry clusters taken by over 40 bird species.
- Black cherry Prunus serotina
Tree · listed in 41 regions. Summer fruit and one of the top caterpillar host trees.
- Serviceberry Amelanchier arborea
Tree · listed in 39 regions. Early-summer berries arrive exactly when nestlings are being fed.
Full guide: how to attract red-shouldered hawks →
Frequently asked
Which hawk is at my bird feeder?
In the East, a hawk bursting through cover at feeders is usually a Cooper's or Sharp-shinned Hawk, not a buteo. Red-tailed and Red-shouldered Hawks take larger prey in more open or wooded settings.
Do Red-tailed and Red-shouldered Hawks fight?
Red-tails are larger and dominate in direct disputes, and Great Horned Owls prey on both. Red-shouldered Hawks defend their wooded territories vigorously in spring.
Why does a Red-tailed Hawk have no red tail when young?
Immatures have banded grey-brown tails. The brick-red tail appears when they molt into adult plumage at about 18 months.
Sources
- Red-tailed Hawk — All About Birds, Cornell Lab of Ornithology
- Red-shouldered Hawk — All About Birds, Cornell Lab of Ornithology
- Red-shouldered Hawk — Audubon Guide to North American Birds
Timing reflects typical patterns for the region as a whole; local dates vary with elevation and year. Check the linked eBird bar charts for your county.